Idol Interactive Results (4/04)
It was hard to see how the contestants would top last week, but overall last night’s performances delivered. The Peel Community displayed their passion for the Idol performances as well as the Peel engagement platform, cheering and booing from the comfort of their couch. In case you missed this week, download the Peel app on iTunes and be sure to join us for next week’s excitement. Remember, the more you cheer and boo, the better your chances to win an all-expenses paid trip for 4 to Hollywood and tickets to an Idols Live! concert at the end of the season.
This week it was 80’s Night, with the contestants tackling some of the classics of this memorable music decade. After some fashion inspiration from Tommy Hilfiger, Jimmy Iovine collaborated with special guests Gwen Stafani and Tony Kanal from No Doubt to help the performers navigate this important week. As always, by the time Ryan Seacrest opened the official Fox voting, the Peel Community had weighed in and could immediately see their predicted results on the leaderboard.
Top (and Bottom) of the Charts
There were some fantastic performances this week — and a couple that were less impressive. Let’s take a look at the best and worst from last night, as determined by the Peel Community.
At the top of last night’s leaderboard was Colton Dixon who blew the audience away with his rendition of Cyndi Lauper’s “Time After Time.” In second place was Skylar Laine who closed out the show and surprised the judges by stepping out of her country comfort zone and performed Bette Midler’s “Wind Beneath My Wings.” While both performances received vocal approval from Peel Community, Colton tallied a Live Audience Reaction approval rating of 73% (see his final performance card above).
Unfortunately, things were more difficult at the bottom of the leaderboard. According to the Peel Community, the bottom three performers will include
- Jessica
- Elise
- DeAndre
and DeAndre could be out tonight despite giving a consistent performance and opening the show with DeBarge's “I Like It.” Ryan asked DeAndre if he felt like going first would hurt his chances and according to the Peel Community it just might. Judge Jennifer Lopez continued her public rallying for DeAndre, which seemed to work in his favor last week.
Audience Reaction Highlights and Lowlights
According to the Peel Live Audience Reaction chart, the most cheered highlights from last night’s show featured
- Top performances from Colton and Skylar
- Phillip teaming up with his brother to do a rocking rendition of Genesis’ “That’s All”
- Joshua’s soulful rendition on Simply Red’s “If You Don’t Know Me by Now,” which received the only standing ovation from the judges last night for a single performance
Meanwhile, the Peel Community voiced their displeasure by booing these lowlights, including
- Both DeAndre’s solo performance as well as his duet with Hollie
- Despite being one of mentor Gwen Stafani’s favorite singers on the show, Elise received her share of boos during her rendition of “I Want to Know What Love is”
Phillip’s Performance with His Brother
Last night Phillip Phillips had his brother-in-law and musical mentor on stage with him playing guitar and singing backup vocals during his performance. Phillip has consistently been a top performer and fan favorite. Fans were vocal in anticipation of his performance, even during the commercial break. During the intro to his video there was a slight increase in boos. The boos got louder during his performance, but then there was a big spike in cheers at the beginning of his song followed by a lull as people focused more on his great performance. A second big increase in cheers followed at the end of his song. The cheering went down to a fairly normal level during the judging and then went back up again when Ryan chatted with Phillip and invited his brother over to join in the conversation. The Peel Community enjoyed the family connection and hearing from Phillip’s brother.
Judging the Judges
For this week’s judging results we saw a return to form as once again Judge Jennifer Lopez received the most feedback overall, and was once again the judge the Peel Community disagreed with most strongly as she recorded the lowest net approval rating at 55%. On the positive side, Judge Randy Jackson was the judge that the Community most agreed with — although by only a narrow margin — with a net approval rating of 61%.
Duet Performance Feedback
Last night’s duet performances seemed to garner more love from the Community then the previous week’s trio performances. Both Jessica (with Joshua) and Elise (with Phillip) received more cheers for their duets then during their solo performances. Colton showed off his versatility by singing a country duet with Skylar to “Islands in the Stream.” Joshua and Jessica’s rendition of “I Knew You Were Waiting” received a standing ovation from the judges, with JLo predicting that the pair would be the final two to take the whole competition. The Community was less then friendly with DeAndre and Hollie’s performance of “I’m So Excited.” Later Hollie, despite receiving decent marks from the Peel Community was cut down to size by the judges in probably one of the harshest critiques of the night.
Tune in tonight to see if the Peel Community agrees with the official American Idol voting. We’re looking forward to next week and another Idol Interactive Experience from Peel.
Enjoy the show!
Your friends at Peel















